Why You Shouldn’t Compliment Weight Loss, and What to Say Instead

You could have the perfect of intentions when commenting on somebody’s weight reduction, however there are higher methods to supply a praise.

Image Credit: monkeybusinessimages/iStock/GettyImages

Let’s do an experiment: Raise your hand should you’ve ever mentioned “Oh my gosh, did you drop some pounds? You look superb!” Probably nearly all of us, proper?

While you would possibly suppose you are being considerate by acknowledging somebody’s weight reduction, your praise might need unintended, unexpected penalties. Put merely, a body-image-related comment — irrespective of how flattering it is meant to be — might do extra hurt than good.

We spoke with Juhee Jhalani, PhD, a New York City-based scientific psychologist, about why you must by no means congratulate somebody for dropping kilos, plus different methods to go with an individual with affirming alternate options.

1. It Enforces the Thin Ideal

When we bathe somebody with reward for shedding kilos, what we’re implicitly speaking is thinner equals higher or extra enticing.

“If losing a few pounds is strengthened by our family and friends, then unconsciously we’re more likely to intention for that,” Jhalani says.

Here’s why: We’re wired to please individuals and interact in behaviors that can lead us to be socially accepted. Hence, we are likely to repeat behaviors — like losing a few pounds — which are positively strengthened.

Unsurprisingly, this skinny ideally suited contributes to anti-fat attitudes. We could develop into terrified of being judged or socially rejected for gaining weight and anxious about shedding attraction or acknowledgement from our mates and important others, Jhalani says. Consequently, we could even begin to physique disgrace ourselves, she provides.

2. It Can Encourage Disordered Behaviors

A seemingly harmless remark about how skinny somebody seems could be a main set off, particularly for these scuffling with disordered eating.

When an individual with an consuming dysfunction is praised for weight reduction (or, conversely, fat-shamed), she or he is more likely to keep away from weight achieve in any respect prices by partaking in dysfunctional behaviors like proscribing meals, binge consuming, purging or excessively exercising, Jhalani says.

“What could also be a perfect measurement or weight for you is probably not for another person or their tradition.”

3. The Weight Loss Might Not Be Intentional

Newsflash: Not everyone seems to be attempting to drop some pounds. In truth, important weight reduction might be an indication that one thing extra critical is occurring in somebody’s life.

“Now greater than ever, amidst the COVID-19 pandemic, we have no idea what an individual or a household could also be going by,” Jhalani says. “We should take into account that weight reduction is likely one of the signs of despair, power bodily sickness or an consuming dysfunction.”

Weight loss can be related to grief, from mourning the demise of a beloved one or possibly shedding a job and monetary safety.

All that is to say, do not assume an individual’s weight reduction is intentional. Someone could merely be struggling mentally, bodily or emotionally.

4. It Implies the Person Looked Bad or Worse Before

Sometimes your well-meaning touch upon somebody’s weight reduction could be a backhanded praise. An individual on the receiving finish of your flattery might imagine, “If I look higher now, how did I look earlier than?” In different phrases, if you congratulate an individual for happening a pants measurement, you are basically inferring that they regarded worse previous to weight reduction.

And, once more, this units up a vicious cycle the place we equate our value with look (particularly thinness), which may result in an unhealthy relationship with food and a distorted physique picture.

So, to keep away from offending somebody or inflicting them anxiousness, Jhalani recommends conserving your judgement to your self: “What could also be a perfect measurement or weight for you is probably not for another person or their tradition.”

A remark like “you look comfortable” may also help shift the dialog from appearances to well being and wellbeing.

Image Credit: Hinterhaus Productions/DigitalVision/GettyImages

Think of different individuals’s our bodies as non-public property — you do not need to trespass with body-centric feedback. Here’s the right way to keep wholesome boundaries and embrace, settle for and respect individuals for who they’re with out ever bringing weight reduction into the dialog.

1. Ask Inviting Questions

Questions like “How are you?,” “How’s life?” and “How are you maintaining with all the pieces?” welcome the particular person to share no matter it’s they really feel snug disclosing (whether or not that pertains to weight or life usually).

More importantly, it shifts the dialog from one thing superficial like seems to one thing inward, which is extra significant.

This strategy additionally communicates that you just care about what is going on on in an individual’s life past the outside. And expressing concern for our family members’ well-being is particularly vital now.

“The world wants extra compassion and empathy than ever throughout these [difficult] instances,” Jhalani says.


Avoid questions like “What’s new?”​ “This could appear to be a benign query, but it surely truly induces efficiency anxiousness,” Jhalani says. It implies that we will need to have one thing novel or thrilling to share. “This turns into much more tough through the pandemic the place nothing is new,” she says.

2. Express That You’re Happy to See Them

Say issues like “It’s nice to see you in the present day” or “I’m so glad that we received collectively.” This communicates that spending time with them is effective (and this has nothing to do with how a lot weight they misplaced or how they give the impression of being).

“I like your power in the present day” or “You look comfortable” will be good dialog starters, Jhalani says. This additionally shifts the main focus from discuss of bodily look to well being and wellness.

4. Focus on Non-Appearance-Related Praise

Celebrate others for his or her core values and never for the way they give the impression of being or their clothes measurement.

“Take a second even earlier than you meet or greet somebody and mirror mindfully on what’s internally stunning about them,” Jhalani says. And then inform them! The extra we deal with the inside, the much less we equate our value with weight.

Recommended For You

About the Author: Adrian

Leave a Reply